home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=89TT1962>
- <title>
- July 31, 1989: Adrift In The Doldrums
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1989
- July 31, 1989 Doctors And Patients
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- BUSINESS, Page 32
- Special Report: The Big Slowdown
- Adrift in the Doldrums
- </hdr><body>
- <p>As the economy weakens, the Federal Reserve will have to steer
- carefully to avoid a recession
- </p>
- <p>By Barbara Rudolph
- </p>
- <p> The words sounded like those of a business leader lecturing
- the U.S. central bank about the dangers of letting the economy
- slump too far: "It is prudent for the Federal Reserve to
- recognize the risk that such softness (in the economy)
- conceivably could accumulate and deepen, resulting in a
- substantial downturn in activity." Yet the statement came from
- Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan, who went public with a surprisingly
- frank assessment last week that, at least for the moment, a
- recession has replaced inflation as the leading threat to the
- U.S. economy. In his midyear report to Congress, Greenspan
- confirmed that since early June, the Fed had been allowing
- interest rates to fall in an attempt to prevent the sluggishness
- from becoming too pronounced. Said he: "What we seek to avoid
- is an unnecessary and destructive recession."
- </p>
- <p> The signals are abundant that the nearly seven-year-old
- expansion is stagnating. Retail sales are anemic, business
- inventories are growing, industrial output is shrinking, and
- the housing industry is struggling. Economists almost uniformly
- agree that growth during the next year will be very slow, but
- are divided about whether the U.S. will fall into a recession.
- The optimists forecast a "soft landing," characterized by
- minimal growth but no severe dislocation; the pessimists believe
- the long-running expansion is due for a bona fide recession,
- with widespread bankruptcies, loan defaults and layoffs.
- </p>
- <p> The Bush Administration last week acknowledged the
- economy's weakened position when it predicted growth of only
- 2.7% for the year, down from the Reagan Administration's
- five-month-old projection of 3.5%. The White House forecasters,
- looking through the rose-colored glasses favored by most
- Administration economists, calculate a growth rate of 2.6% for
- 1990, but a consensus of 52 economists surveyed by the Blue Chip
- Economic Indicators holds that the economy will grow at a rate
- of less than 1.5% during the final half of the year and at about
- the same sluggish pace in 1990. Says Norman Robertson, chief
- economist at Pittsburgh's Mellon Bank: "The slowdown is now a
- reality. It has arrived." Two out of three of the Blue Chip
- forecasters expect that the economy will fall into a recession
- by sometime next year.
- </p>
- <p> Despite slipping retail sales, most consumers profess
- relatively little fear about the economy. In a TIME/CNN poll
- conducted last week by Yankelovich Clancy Shulman, 6 out of 10
- adults described current conditions as fairly good or very
- good, down only a trifle compared with January. Looking ahead
- to the next twelve months, 72% expected conditions to stay the
- same or improve, while just 24% of those polled saw the economy
- getting worse. Asked about their spending plans in the coming
- year, 65% said they thought it would be a good time to buy a
- major household item -- a refrigerator, for example, or a
- television set.
- </p>
- <p> To some extent, however, action belies bravado. Consumer
- spending, which typically accounts for two-thirds of economic
- activity and provided most of the oomph for the expansion, is
- starting to falter. Auto sales have stalled dramatically,
- contributing to a drop in total retail sales of 0.4% last month
- and 0.1% in May, the first back-to-back monthly declines since
- September and October of 1986. Industry is showing the same
- trend. U.S. factories operated at 83.5% of capacity in June,
- down from a high of 84.3% in January, a strong indicator that
- the economy has passed the peak in its current growth cycle.
- </p>
- <p> Despite concerns that the expansion will falter, most
- economists believe a modest slowdown is necessary to suppress
- inflation, which had grown particularly stubborn in the past
- two years. Consumer prices rose at an annual rate of 5.9% during
- the first half of 1989, up from 4.1% last year. "The economy
- was running too fast for its own good," says Francis Schott,
- chief economist for Equitable Life Assurance. "It was working
- itself up to an inflationary frenzy."
- </p>
- <p> Sensing the inflationary pressures early last year, the Fed
- tightened credit and dampened growth. In June the Fed was
- helped in its task by falling energy costs. The Government
- reported last week that consumer prices last month increased at
- an annual rate of just 2%, the slowest pace in 16 months. While
- Greenspan said he sees inflation as a lingering menace, he
- confirmed that for the moment it has been eclipsed by a need to
- keep the economy afloat. As a result, interest rates on
- three-month Treasury bills have fallen from a high of 9.4% in
- late March to 7.9% last week. The clarity of the Fed's purpose
- has sent Wall Street on a bullish stampede to post-October
- 1987-crash highs. Last week the Dow Jones average climbed 53
- points, closing at 2607.36.
- </p>
- <p> Economists have been hoping that a modest slowdown would
- help ease another thorny problem, the U.S. trade deficit, by
- suppressing the American appetite for imported goods. So far,
- that has not happened. The Government announced last week that
- the trade deficit swelled to $10.2 billion in May, up from $8.3
- billion in April. Especially troubling was a 4.3% rise in
- imports, to a record $40.7 billion, which suggested that foreign
- brand names remain a powerful enticement for U.S. shoppers.
- </p>
- <p> Some economists believe the slack period will be
- short-lived and will be followed by renewed growth, a scenario
- that has them searching for metaphors. David Hale, chief
- economist of Chicago's Kemper Financial Services, characterizes
- the slowdown as an "output pause." Geoffrey Moore, an economics
- professor at Columbia University, talks of a "stutter step."
- Economist Lyle Gramley, a former Fed governor, says that by late
- 1990 the slowdown may be followed by a period of "economic
- refreshment."
- </p>
- <p> Some of the optimists expect the expansion to be kept
- afloat by three major forces: exports, housing and capital
- spending. No one thinks exports will repeat the explosive growth
- of last year, when sales abroad jumped nearly 30%, thanks
- largely to a declining U.S. dollar. One reason U.S. firms should
- find receptive markets overseas is that the economies of Western
- Europe and Japan are still rapidly expanding. European Community
- members are expected to sustain 3% growth in 1989, and Japan is
- likely to show a 5% gain for the fiscal year ending next March.
- </p>
- <p> For the moment, though, U.S. exports are moving
- erratically. During the first four months of the year, America's
- overseas sales grew at a healthy 15% annual rate, but fell 0.9%,
- to $30.5 billion, in May. Those who predict a soft landing see
- the one-month reversal as only a temporary setback; others are
- more troubled. Says Allen Sinai, chief economist of the Boston
- Co. Economic Advisors: "The trade-deficit report is yet another
- sign of the potential for a recession sometime within the next
- six to nine months."
- </p>
- <p> Homebuilding could be another strong foundation for the
- economy. Real estate usually takes a tumble just before a
- recession begins and stages a comeback as a recovery takes hold.
- This time some economists predict that the housing industry,
- aided by falling mortgage rates, may bounce back later in the
- year. Last week the Government reported that housing starts
- during June rose 7%, to an annual rate of 1.4 million. Even so,
- some experts are cautious about predicting a housing boon
- because the rise was entirely attributable to an increase in
- multifamily houses and apartment buildings. There was no growth
- in single-family-home construction, which forms the largest part
- of the industry.
- </p>
- <p> While soft-landing scenarios provide reassuring reading,
- some economists think such forecasts belong on the fiction
- shelf. If U.S. economic history is any guide, a soft landing is
- a long shot. That kind of gentle slowdown occurred only once
- before, in 1967, when the military buildup during the Viet Nam
- War fueled a demand for capital goods.
- </p>
- <p> If a recession does occur, it may well be triggered by a
- sharp erosion in consumer confidence. Americans are saddled with
- hefty debt loads and could easily become jittery if the economy
- weakens. Says Doris Drury, president of the Center for Business
- and Economic Forecasting in Denver: "I'm leery of debt. If we
- could have a recession on the order of 1981 or '82, that could
- be a real problem." Consumer debt has increased from $1.7
- trillion to $3.3 trillion since the expansion began in late
- 1982. If Americans cut back abruptly on their spending, the
- effects would ripple through the economy. Businesses would
- respond to the sales falloff by reducing their own spending and
- laying off workers, which would spark a further drop in consumer
- spending.
- </p>
- <p> Deborah Johnson, a senior economist for Prudential-Bache
- Securities, foresees the possibility of what she dubs a
- "couch-potato recession." Her scenario: well-off baby boomers,
- who have already purchased their compact-disc players and
- microwave ovens and typically have children to provide for, will
- spend more time at home and do less shopping. According to
- Prudential-Bache's Yuppie Consumption Index, these consumers cut
- their spending 2.4% in the period from December through May.
- </p>
- <p> The tremendous buildup of business debt during the long
- expansion leaves the economy even more exposed to the effects
- of a recession. Since late 1982, corporate debt has more than
- doubled, from $1.1 trillion to $2.2 trillion. Investors in junk
- bonds, the high-yield securities that account for $225 billion
- in debt, could be among the first to feel the pinch. According
- to a study conducted for a group of junk-bond issuers by the
- economic consulting firm Data Resources, 1 out of every 8 will
- default if the economy falls into a soft landing. A major
- recession could produce a 1-in-5 default rate over five years.
- This year some $3 billion worth of junk bonds either have
- defaulted or were forced into a restructuring. The failure rate
- is well ahead of last year, when about $4 billion in junk bonds
- collapsed during the entire twelve months.
- </p>
- <p> In the final analysis, everyone from corporate chieftains
- to cab drivers realizes that the expansion cannot go on
- forever. "Someday, some event will end the extraordinary string
- of economic advances that has prevailed since late 1982,"
- Greenspan told Congress last week. So far, Greenspan has
- provided a delicate touch in stifling inflation without making
- the kind of sudden moves that could trigger a recession. The
- U.S. may be in for only a brief and relatively innocuous
- reversal like the one in 1961 rather than the painful
- contraction of 1981-82, when the unemployment rate averaged
- 8.7%. The current slowdown "is not a good thing, but it's the
- cost of a good thing," says economist George Stigler, a Nobel
- laureate and professor at the University of Chicago. Americans
- can only hope that if they pay now, they can fly again later.
- </p>
- <p>--Gisela Bolte/Washington and Thomas McCarroll/New York
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-